Guantánamo Bay 2.0? The rise of legal violence inside US detention centers

Credit: engin akyurt / Unsplash

The United States government has a long history of dehumanizing foreigners both inside and outside its borders. The treatment of prisoners in Guantánamo Bay and of migrants currently detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) provide just two recent examples of the extensive use of criminalizing language to justify targeting these groups. The George W. Bush administration routinely labeled those incarcerated in Guantánamo Bay as “terrorists” and associated them with the September 11 attacks, often without direct evidence. Today, the Donald J. Trump administration labels migrants as “animals,” “criminals,” and “rapists.” This type of dehumanizing language suggests that detainees do not deserve legal rights, and it leads to the broad erosion of the civil protections that shield people—whether or not they are US citizens—from arrest without charge and trial or harsh and unusual punishment. 

The state’s curtailment of due process and other civil rights in these cases has led to a rise in legal violence: harm inflicted by a government body while enforcing state policy. Many held in Guantánamo Bay have claimed that members of the United States military physically and mentally assaulted them during their detention. Similar abuse is still taking place today against migrants in ICE detention centers. Detainees’ testimonies of violent punishments by ICE agents are all too reminiscent of the experiences of Guantánamo Bay prisoners.

The US government and military have not taken the lessons of the War on Terror to heart, and the United States is still using violence against people it detains. There has been very little pressure from legislators or the courts to dissuade the government from using legal violence—a direct failure of the very systems that allowed this kind of violence to become legal in the first place.

Mass incarceration and violence toward migrants

Since Trump took office as president of the United States for the second time, his administration has pushed ICE to detain anyone deemed to be residing in the country illegally. This has led to the mass incarceration of Latinos and other migrants all over the nation. According to The Guardian, a total of 68,400 individuals were held in detention as of December 2025. The majority of detainees have no previous criminal record. A recent Human Rights Watch report documented dozens of executive orders rolling back migrants’ right to due process, guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment, and limiting their ability to seek legal redress while detained. 

These new executive orders have systematically allowed the state to punish those detained prior to legal due process or the filing of charges. The result is legal violence inflicted against migrants detained in defiance of their constitutional rights. For example, officers are now legally allowed to interrogate suspected illegal migrants using violence and make arrests without warrants.

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) has done very little to limit the powers granted to ICE. In fact, some recent SCOTUS rulings have expanded ICE’s powers. In September 2025, SCOTUS eliminated restrictions on ICE’s use of racial profiling when making arrests. In the case of Noem v. Vasquez-Perdomo SCOTUS ruled that ICE could conduct raids in public places opening the door to using race, ethnicity, and language to determine their targets. This is unambiguously racial profiling and encourages violence toward especially Latinos regardless of their immigration status.  

Several reports documenting migrant accounts of violence committed by detention officers and ICE have been released since Trump’s executive orders and SCOTUS’s legal decisions on immigration enforcement. One of many migrants who spoke with the ACLU reported that detention officers had beaten him, breaking his tooth and damaging his ear to the point that he began to lose hearing. This violence was carried out in one of the largest detention centers in the country, located at the Fort Bliss military base in Texas. 

One man in a Florida detention center, speaking to Human Rights Watch, recalled officers turning up the air conditioning to intentionally freezing levels in the cells. Several people in the same location are also being denied life-saving medications needed to treat chronic illnesses. 

Are detention centers the new Guantánamo Bay?

Guantánamo Bay was established in 2002 to detain individuals believed to be linked with the perpetrators of the September 11 attacks. The Center for Constitutional Rights has outlined the violent experiences of prisoners detained at Guantánamo Bay, which included practices like those used today in ICE detention centers. 

The Bush administration authorized the use of violent practices in Guantánamo Bay by declaring that those imprisoned there were “unlawful enemy combatants” and thus ineligible for the protections of the Geneva Conventions. By eliminating application of the Geneva Conventions, the Bush administration removed a major barrier imposed by international law to prevent the torture of prisoners. More recently, the Trump administration has similarly rejected the Geneva Conventions by cutting funding for the United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR) and condemning their operations.

The Center for Constitutional Rights has shared the experience of Abu Zubaydah, who was subjected to waterboarding, sleep deprivation, stress positions, and confinement inside a coffin-sized box. Ahmed al-Darbi similarly reported that officers played painfully loud music for several hours and chilled his cell to extremely cold temperatures until he confessed to the crime he was accused of. The government framed these practices as interrogation, but it’s clear that they constitute torture. 

Many of the prisoners in Guantánamo Bay were never formally charged with any crime. Instead, they were imprisoned indefinitely and subjected to intense and violent interrogation tactics in hopes of eliciting confessions. These abusive practices were justified by a Military Order that allowed prisoners suspected of terrorism to be held outside US jurisdiction. This was an intentional move to limit the court’s reach and provide for increased use of force against those held in Guantánamo Bay and impunity for the officers who carried it out. 

Ending legal violence

Like many who were imprisoned in Guantánamo Bay, most of the migrants in detention today have not been convicted of any crime. Legal violence does not change; only its target does.

To prevent the continuation of legal violence, we must challenge the system. The executive and military orders that allowed violence and mistreatment of prisoners in Guantánamo Bay laid the foundation for the laws currently supporting ICE’s violent and indiscriminate campaign of immigration enforcement. The United States Constitution already prohibits abuse inside penitentiaries and detention centers. Cruel and unusual punishments are strictly prohibited. 

The courts must consistently apply the protections provided by the United States Constitution, and they must disempower ICE. This includes protecting due process rights for migrants, firing officers who act with racial bias, eliminating officers’ rights to interrogate detainees using violence, and investigating each facility where abuse has been reported. If these steps are not taken, the use of legal violence and the policies of impunity that underpin them will only grow.