Changing gender realities in MENA: Fostering social entrepreneurship
Social enterprises help change gender realities in MENA to make them more equal.
A woman enrolled on the cash-for-work tailoring programme assembles the hand-crafted baby kits at the ‘Oasis Center for Resilience and Empowerment of Women and Girls’ operated by UN Women in the Za’atari refugee camp in Jordan. UN Women/Christopher Herwig (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)
In the area of women’s entrepreneurship, social enterprises are especially promising. These enterprises have a smaller gender gap in ownership than commercial enterprises. Globally, male ownership in commercial enterprise outpaces female ownership two to one, with Middle Eastern enterprises showing more drastic divides. In Jordan, for example, firms with a majority ownership by women represent only 4% of businesses and 85% of commercial enterprises have no women involved in ownership. In contrast, 44% of Jordanian social enterprises are led by women.
Social enterprises come in many forms, each of which employ entrepreneurial approaches and capacities to solve social problems. The term “social enterprise” is used to describe three primary entities: 1) commercial enterprises with social impacts (e.g., businesses that solve social problems such as LuminAID, 2) non-profit organizations who form a business to generate employment and/or a revenue source for funding their services (e.g., GroFive which was established by the nonprofit Because International), and 3) entities that seek ways to catalyze social transformation through shifting the social contexts in which social problems are embedded as is the case for organizations such as the Ashoka Foundation.
The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region has more emerging social entrepreneurs than commercial . It has been argued that this engagement derives from a growing interest in achieving sustained social impact and increasing volunteerism among the youth in the region, leading to an increased sense of social commitment and rejection of the profit-motivated models of traditional businesses. For example, social enterprises in MENA are already filling gaps in public service provision, addressing community challenges, and promoting economic inclusion through job creation, upskilling, or providing goods and services to marginalized populations. These elements position social entrepreneurship in MENA to play an important role in achieving national and international economic and social development goals.
Transformative leadership challenges structures and ideologies that justify and perpetuate gender inequality and power imbalances by advancing women’s participation, leadership, and rights.
But behind these promising rates of female participation in MENA, persistent gender inequalities lurk and result in women’s restricted access to financial support and limited asset ownership (often due to patriarchal norms in laws governing household income, land ownership and/or inheritance laws in the region), and women’s unpaid care and domestic responsibilities. As a result, women’s (commercial and social) enterprises are, on average, smaller than male-owned enterprises, with less inventory, fewer clients, and more limited credit options. More recently, the COVID-19 pandemic has heightened the impacts of these inequalities and reduced women’s capacity to be resilient to the pandemic and its aftermath.
Women’s social enterprises stand to be especially vulnerable to these shocks for two reasons. First, government-instituted financial support programs are likely to exclude social enterprises because few countries in MENA have established clear regulatory systems for these enterprises, and many women-owned ones operate informally. Second, potential austerity measures and redirection of national public expenditure and international donor organizations towards urgent demands threatens to reduce the funding available for social enterprises regionally.
The need for a gender transformative approach to social enterprises
Given the promising role of social enterprises in addressing key social, economic, and environmental challenges and the strong representation of women in the ownership of these enterprises, governments must establish transformative business, legal, and regulatory environments with a focus on gender. Transformative leadership challenges structures and ideologies that justify and perpetuate gender inequality and power imbalances by advancing women’s participation, leadership, and rights.
For a transformative approach to social enterprises in the MENA region, three elements must be considered: decent work opportunities; appropriate social protection; and developing responsive gender justice frameworks.
(1) Decent work opportunities and sustainability
The MENA region must build decent work opportunities for a growing workforce in an economy dominated by small operational sizes and informality. Small businesses encompass a large portion of private sector employers across the region: businesses with five or fewer employees dominate the private sector in Egypt (60%), Jordan (40%), and Tunisia (37%). Often these enterprises operate in the informal economy and contribute important job opportunities for women, youth, and other vulnerable groups.
(2) Design inclusive and gender-sensitive social protection programs available to social entrepreneurs
Social protection programs (i.e., social insurance, pensions, healthcare, and disability payments) have direct impacts on women’s multiple roles, especially their unpaid care and domestic work. In the MENA, women have the highest unpaid care work burden globally, spending 4.7 times more time in unpaid care work than men. Building appropriate social protection requires a full accounting of the pressures that any entrepreneurial activities place on women’s unpaid care and reproductive labor responsibilities. There is a need to maximize inclusion of informal and unregistered social enterprises, where women are overrepresented.
(3) Develop a gender justice framework for social enterprises
Developing a gender transformative social enterprise framework promotes wider changes to existing economic and social structures that underlie existing gender relations in the household, market, community, and state. Appropriate policies must recognize that women are not a single, homogenous group; women’s experiences intersect with their ethnic, geographic, socioeconomic, educational, disability, age, and other identities. Such intersections magnify existing inequalities and vulnerabilities that define women’s workplace experiences and threaten to marginalize women who face different and multiple systems of oppression.
In a region where gender parities are amongst the worst in the world, gender justice and women’s economic empowerment are hard to achieve without a gender transformative approach. Such an approach requires multiple-layer interventions that involve redesigning the formal (e.g., laws and regulations, social protection programs, taxation and financial access) as well as the informal systems (e.g., social norms that assign unpaid care and domestic work to women) that reduce the impact of women’s social enterprises. The experiences of women social enterprise owners in MENA show that refusing to apply gender transformative approaches to entrepreneurship hinders the social and economic transformations that will allow the region to “build back better” in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic. It also shows that focusing on individual enterprises will not lead to a social change without addressing the collective’s needs and creating a supportive ecosystem that transforms the way societies look at gender justice and women’s rights.
This piece is part of a blog series focusing on the gender dimensions of business and human rights. The blog series is in partnership with the Business & Human Rights Resource Centre, the Danish Institute for Human Rights and OpenGlobalRights. The views expressed in the series are those of the authors. For more on the latest news and resources on gender, business, and human rights, visit this portal.
Melissa Langworthy, PhD is an affiliate researcher at Ladysmith and the Principal Researcher for Inclusive Market Systems at Includovate. She is a feminist economist specializing in analyzing the impact of gender norms in women’s economic empowerment programs and policies, especially entrepreneurship. You can follow her at @M_LangworthyPhD.
Hadeel Qazzaz, EdD is a feminist activist and researcher. Currently she works as the MENA regional gender justice coordinator at Oxfam International. Her work focuses on gender-based violence and women empowerment. You can follow her at @hadeelazzaz.